Best Pie in Salt Lake City

Let me preface this post by saying there’s nothing quite like making delicious homemade pie and there’s NOTHING like enjoying that pie with friends and family on Thanksgiving day (my favorite holiday!). But sometimes life hits you and there’s also nothing like paying someone else for a job well done. If you live in SLC and consume copious amounts of pie for the month of November year-round, I think you’ll enjoy this post featuring the best pie in Salt Lake City! Thanks for reading.

SEE ALSO: TOP 10 PLACES TO EAT IN SALT LAKE CITY

The Ultimate Guide to Eating in Salt Lake City

Eat your way across the Wasatch Front with restaurants recommendations you can trust. Because life’s too short to eat bad food.

3. The Dodo

Cody and I went on our first date here so I’m allll sorts of nostalgic for this SLC hot spot. They’re famous for their melt in your mouth tollhouse pie and make everything in house and from scratch. This beautiful key lime pie is one of their more popular pies, alongside the banana cream cheese and the chocolate almond mousse. Their pies are gorgeous, consistent, and enough to share for two (#datenight). Unquestionably a tack on our list featuring the best pie in Salt Lake City.  

The Dodo

$$$$ American (Traditional)

1355 E 2100 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84105 801-486-2473

2. Left Fork Grill

Left Fork Grill is everything you want in a sit-down diner with regulars at the bar, waitresses with sass, and food that’s shamelessly cooked in lard. My mum took me here a few years ago for a smoked salmon scramble and a slice of home made pie. YUM. As I prepared for this post and brought home wayyyy too much/not enough slices of pie, my husband declared this slice of raspberry cream pie the *best* that he had during my pie extravaganza. It’s their most popular pie for good reason. I also have an undying love for their blueberry pie.

Left Fork Grill

$$$$ Diners, Desserts, Breakfast & Brunch

68 W 3900 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84107 801-266-4322

1. Tradition

Our favorite spot for a slice of homemade pie in Salt Lake City is Tradition. It’s a southern restaurant just across the street from Liberty Park (on the north side) and they have homemade pie every day that is straight from the pie Gods. Flaky, perfect crust, paired with delicious filling is the key to our hearts.

Tradition

$$$$ Comfort Food, Southern

501 East 900 South, Salt Lake City, UT 84105 (385) 202-7167

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Go check out the Crust Club! It’s amazing, handmade dinner and dessert pies that they deliver right to your doorstep. I think it’s at crustclub.com.

  2. Awesome list!!! I had a great time visiting each of them! Per NEEDING to buy various pies from each on this list, I think by now I’ve spent (much to my wife’s dismay) at least 3 or 4 hundred dollars on pie! Totally worth it! I think my family and co-workers are pretty much sick of me going on about what makes a truly exceptional pie 🙂 Out of each of these, my personal favorite is June Pie. Thanks for the great post!

    1. Hi Steven! I am so glad you like my list! Haha eating out can get expensive but if the food is good then (in my opinion) it’s worth it!! Love June Pie! Thanks for reading 🙂

  3. We just tried to order pie at Penny Ann’s and our waitress said she isn’t making them anymore. Darn! We’re excited to try the rest of the pies on this list, though.