Best Missoula Restaurants: Top 10 Picks By A Foodie

Contributors:
Brooke Eliason

Welcome to a foodie’s guide to Missoula restaurants. Missoula Montana is officially one of my favorite cities in the entire United States. If you have any familiarity with this mountain town it might be because you watched Brad Pitt as a young buck starring in A River Runs Through It (which I highly recommend), or you might’ve passed through Missoula on your way to Glacier National Park (also highly recommend), or perhaps you had a friend or family member who attended the University of Montana a few years back.

 Regardless of what you know, I’m here to tell you that Missoula is one of the best kept secrets in the entire Northwest. Whether you’re into fly fishing, hiking, mountain biking,  or just living that small-town life, there’s something for nearly everyone. But what unites us all at the end of the day is the food. And there is a lot of fantastic food when it comes to Missoula restaurants. When I typically investigate the dining scene in a smaller city like Missoula, people seem to be more forgiving when it comes to quality and standards. So when we spent four weeks in Missoula earlier this year, I took it upon myself to try nearly every last restaurant in the town to ensure that I had dotted all of my i’s and crossed all of my t’s.

My list of top Missoula restaurants range from high-end dining options to inexpensive hole in the wall gems. So whatever the occasion, next time you find yourself looking for food in Missoula be certain that you’re checking out my list of top 10 restaurants. Thanks for stopping by and enjoy my list!

SEE ALSO: TOP 10 PLACES TO EAT IN BOZEMAN, MONTANA

10. Rattlesnake Gardens Market & Cafe

Tucked away in the beautiful Rattlesnake neighborhood of Missoula is one of the lesser known places to eat- the Rattlesnake Gardens Market & Cafe. This is everything you want in a cozy, quaint, neighborhood cafe. They serve lunch & dinner daily and weekend breakfast. Our favorites include the grilled chicken caesar wrap and the lunch & dinner specials. I’m also a huge fan of their simple breakfast sandwiches on the weekends before taking off for a day hike. Delicious!

Rattlesnake Market & Cafe (2501 Rattlesnake Dr, Missoula, MT // 406.926.3202)

9. The Pearl Cafe

If you’re looking for a great upscale or fine dining option among Missoula restaurants, The Pearl Cafe is a great place to start. This European influenced cafe serves classic menu favorites including filet mignon, grilled salmon with mustard butter, and Idaho Trout. Personal favorites of ours include the french onion soup and the prime flat iron steak, served with smoked goat cheese mashed potatoes, a red wine reduction, sautéed greens, and a marinated mushroom medley. Make reservations ahead of time and dine outside on the patio when the weather is nice.

The Pearl Cafe (231 E Front St, Missoula, MT // 406..541.0231)

8. Tagliare Delicatessen

For those in search of a fantastic sandwich in Missoula, Tagliare Delicatessen is 100% your best bet. This delicatessen, although somewhat ordinary at first glance, serves some of the best craft meats and cheeses in the entire city. Favorite sandwiches include The Kiss (prosciutto, provolone, fig & walnut chutney, arugula & olive oil) and The Zeppelin (turkey, dry salame, pastrami, provolone, greens, tomatoes, onions, oil & vinegar). They also have an amazing selection of local and imported goods including homemade pasta sauces, oils, cheese, and charcuterie.

Tagliare Delicatessen (1433 S Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.830.3049)

7. Five on Black

My favorite fast casual food in Missoula and possibly one of the best fast casual restaurants I’ve ever eaten at is Five on Black. I absolutely love coming here for lunch or dinner here because the food is fast, fresh, healthy (major bonus) and reliable. Step aside to all the dozens of Mexican fast casual joints, Five on Black has something unique to offer with their Brazillian influenced flavors. Choose you base (I like to do a mixture of greens and brown rice), protein (I’m a big fan of their rotisserie cooked chicken), vegetable (sweet potatoes are my favorite), sauce (if you don’t get the spicy coconut you’re doing it wrong), and toppings (give me all the chimichurri and farofa). And shame on you if you don’t finish it off with one of their adorable little Brazillian cheese rolls. One of the best Missoula restaurants no doubt!

Five on Black (325 N Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.926.1860)

6. The Catalyst Cafe

I’m going to shoot you straight when it comes to The Catalyst Cafe. It’s busy, it’s probably more hipster than you’re comfortable with, and the ownership is rumored to be on the pretentious side, but the food is simply amazing and if you’re in search of the best Missoula restaurants The Catalyst Cafe most definitely needs to be on your list. They serve breakfast & lunch each day and although there are several menu options to choose from we highly recommend starting with breakfast/brunch items. Some of the best menu items include the 3 egg omelet, huevos rancheros, and the chilaquiles. And if you’re really feeling it make sure to order any entree with a side of their popular cheddar potato casserole. Yums.

The Catalyst Cafe (111 N Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.542.1337)

5. Plonk

While dining at Plonk I truly felt like two worlds were colliding- the small town feel that I had been engulfed in for weeks and a chic, sophisticated “big city” feel that the atmosphere, aesthetic, and menu of Plonk presents. Several locals enjoy coming to Plonk for the music or wine, but for me it was all about the food. Every single dish we tried was flavorful, fresh, and detail-oriented. Plonk’s menu changes seasonally, so you won’t likely find the same menu items each time you’re visiting, but we recommend asking for the chef’s recommendation and treating yourself to a couple of appetizers, an entree, and dessert of course. A definite must try when it comes to Missoula restaurants.

Plonk Missoula (322 N Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.926.1791)

4. The Greek Pastry Shop- #1 GYROS

If anything on this list deserves a gold star for being a completely unexpected hidden gem when it comes to Missoula restaurants, it would definitely go to The Greek Pastry Shop, otherwise known to locals as “#1 Gyros”. After our friend Burke from The Notorious P.I.G. told us that we had to stop here for an amazing Greek gyros, we couldn’t resist. Sure enough, these gyros are some of the BEST we have had in our lives. I can taste them right now- fluffy white pita bread, juicy meat with a crispy grilled finish, fresh lettuce and tomato, and feta cheese- all assembled to perfection. The fries were equally exceptional and tasted as though they were double dipped (no calorie counting here). A fantastic hidden gem and extremely affordable with some of the kindest people serving the best food in Missoula!

The Greek Pastry Shop- #1 GYROS! (520 S 5th St W, Missoula, MT // 406.543.6843)

3. Caffe Dolce

Even though we were able to dine here at least three or four times during our four week stay in Missoula, we couldn’t get enough! Decorated with painted ceilings, arched doorways, detailed mosaics, and one of the most beautiful patios in all of town, you’ll walk into this restaurant feeling like you’ve entered a scene in Western Europe. Everything we tried including items from the breakfast/brunch and dinner selections were fantastic. Their menu is constantly evolving depending on the season so you can rest assured knowing that your food will be prepared with local, seasonal ingredients and that each dish comes out of the kitchen with thoughtful preparation. Make sure to finish your meal at Caffe Dolce with some of their house-made gelato or a homemade pastry.

Caffe Dolce (500 Brooks St, Missoula, MT // 406.830.3055)

2. Biga Pizza

Every city whether big or small isn’t complete without a staple pizza joint, and the local favorite among Missoula restaurants is unanimously Biga Pizza. There’s something so enticing about their perfectly chewy hand-tossed crust, adorned with generous amounts of topping from Italian meats to fresh vegetables to nine different cheeses. Our favorite order is a half caramelized goat cheese pizza (caramelized onions, goat cheese, fresh herbs, mozzarella, roasted garlic and olive oil) and half Sicilian (Italian sausage, mascarpone, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, roasted garlic, and olive oil) for a combination that dreams are made of. Order one of their fresh salads to start and be prepared for a wait- especially on the weekends!

Biga Pizza (241 W Main St, Missoula, MT // 406.728.2579)

1. The Notorious P.I.G. BBQ

The unquestionable number one on our list of Missoula restaurants is without hesitation The Notorious P.I.G. BBQ. If there’s only one place you’ll eat at while visiting Missoula make it a meal here. Pit master and owner Burke Homes, is native to the Midwest but in recent years fell in love with Montana and the art of fly fishing.

After training with several world-renowned BBQ experts across the country, he made his way back to Missoula combining favorite renditions of barbecue including Memphis style ribs, Kansas City burnt ends, Texas style brisket, New York City pastrami, and the list goes on. It will be hard to find anything you dislike here because they compromise on nothing. All of the meats and sides are prepared to perfection. Plan accordingly (they do sell out) and prepare yourself for some the best barbecue you’ve had unquestionably in the state of Montana and perhaps in your entire life.

The Notorious P.I.G. BBQ (247 W Front St, Missoula, MT // 406.926.1344)

Bonus: Best Desserts in (and near) Missoula

Because after scouring and searching for the best Missoula restaurants, we couldn’t possibly leave you high and dry when it comes to dessert options. Below is our list in descending order of best picks for a sweet tooth craving while in or near Missoula including bakeries, ice cream shops, etc. Enjoy!

5.  Bernice’s Bakery

For one of the most beloved dessert spots in town, check out Bernice’s Bakery. They have an impressive case of treats including gorgeous cupcakes, brownies and bars, cookies, and pie. Everything is made fresh and the staff are exceptionally thoughtful to help you decide from their many delectable options. Bernice’s Bakery (190 S 3rd St W, Missoula, MT // 406.728.1358)

4. Big Dipper Ice Cream

Before we can to Missoula we were told by several friends and family that Big Dipper Ice Cream was an absolute must try on our list of things to eat! We thoroughly enjoyed this nostalgic Montana ice cream shop and came to this walk-up joint on several occasions to choose from regular or seasonal flavors to enjoy from a freshly made waffle cone. Delicious and worth the hype! Big Dipper Ice Cream (631 S Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.543.5722)

3. Le Petit Outre

The best bakery in all of Missoula, IMHO, was Le Petit Outre, a beautiful and quaint bakery off the main drag of town offering house made breads and pastries including pain au chocolat croissants, lemon poppy ginger scones, hazelnut shortbread, and (my personal favorite) the incredible chocolate bouchon. A beautiful place to stop and grab a sweet or savory treat and a favorite remote workspace for myself on several occasions. Le Petit Outre (129 S 4th St W, Missoula, MT // 406.543.3311)

2. Sweet Peaks Ice Cream

We love the fantastic homemade ice cream at Sweet Peaks! This clean, bright, vibrant storefront (always employed with the kindest folks) serves ice cream with more of an artisanal approach using Montana dairy and high-quality regional ingredients. Favorite classic flavors include the chocolate love and salty caramel. Come to Mama. Sweet Peaks Ice Cream (Suite D, 420 N Higgins Ave, Missoula, MT // 406.549.0028)

1. Windmill Bakery

Let it be known to mankind that the best homemade donut I’ve yet to find was made in the mountains of Montana. The Windmill Village Bakery is a complete hidden gem and a 30 minute drive from Missoula in the tiny town of Ravalli, but if you’re A) on your way to Glacier National Park or B) as committed to finding the best donuts in the world as I am, then game on. Make sure to wait until they’re freshly dipped and all of your glazed donut dreams will come true. I’ve had several of their other house made pastries and treats which are equally as delicious and memorable. Closed on Sunday and Monday- plan accordingly! Windmill Village Bakery (26715 US Highway 93, Ravalli, Montana // 406.745.2270)

SEE ALSO: TOP 10 RESTAURANTS IN WEST YELLOWSTONE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. You got the list right! Maybe Garden’s should be in there… You should try The Klondike in StHelens Oregon try it on Halloween… Google it, Super savory and a flare of comfort. Yum

  2. Did you get a chance to try The Empanada Joint while you were in Missoula? I think this would be right up your alley. Next time, come on in for a taste of Argentina! Glad you gave The Food Mecca in Missoula the attention it so well deserves!

  3. five on black also has a second location thats open 7 days a week in the south crossing shopping center at brooks and reserve.the downtown location closed on sundays.to those that wish to go to windmill bakery?call the phone number first since i believe they have seasonal hours being open.

  4. Hi Brooke, great picks and photos! We’re a new restaurant in town, Rumour Restaurant & Tap House, and would love to have you try us out the next time you visit Missoula. Cheers!